theitalydesk.
← All stories
Instagram cover: Istat: nearly 3 million families lose from the 2027 budget
Cover of our post on Instagram
THIS WEEKIn depth · 4 min read

Istat: nearly 3 million families lose from the 2027 budget

About 3.5 million Italian families would gain from the 2027 budget and nearly 3 million would lose, mostly families with pensioners, according to Istat, Italy's national statistics institute. Its president, Francesco Maria Chelli, presented the estimates to parliament on 11 November 2026. This piece explains which measures Istat looked at, who comes out ahead and who falls behind, why pensioners lose, what "fiscal drag" is and how much it has cost taxpayers since 2021, and what the government, its critics and other public bodies have said.

Where the budget stands

Every year the government sends parliament a budget bill that must become law by 31 December. The 2027 bill is being examined by the budget committees of the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate sitting together, which began hearing institutions, unions and business groups on 9 November. Istat, the Bank of Italy, the Court of Auditors (Corte dei conti) and the Parliamentary Budget Office (UPB), an independent fiscal watchdog, all gave evidence.

Istat expects the economy to grow by 0.9% in 2026 and 0.6% in 2027.

The four measures Istat simulated

Istat ran the bill through its tax and benefit model, which applies the rules to a large sample of real households. It looked at four measures.

MeasureWhat changesWho is affectedAverage effectCost to the state
Income tax (IRPEF), art. 9The 33% rate applies up to €55,000 instead of €50,000, in 2027 onlyAbout 3.7 million taxpayersAbout €450 a year less taxJust under €1.7 billion
Flat-rate regime for the self-employed, art. 9Income ceiling raised from €85,000 to €100,000 (the VAT ceiling stays at €85,000)About 55,000 potential new entrantsAbout €8,000 a year less taxAbout €400 million
Pension indexation, art. 55Annual inflation increase cut for pensions above four times the minimumAbout 3.5 million pensionersAbout €510 a year gross less in 2027A saving (see below)
Bonus for working mothers, art. 57€100 a month, for incomes up to €40,000About 1 million mothersAbout €1,100 a yearNot given in the hearing

IRPEF is Italy's personal income tax. It has three rates, 23%, 33% and 43%, and the first bracket ends at €28,000. The flat-rate regime (regime forfettario) lets small self-employed workers pay a single low rate instead of IRPEF.

For mothers the picture is mixed. Istat says 820,000 who received a €60 monthly bonus in 2026 would get about €460 more a year. About 160,000 who had a full exemption from social security contributions, worth about €1,500 a year on average, would move to the €1,100 bonus and lose around €400.

Who gains and who loses

Taken together, the measures touch about 6.5 million families, one in four, with an average gain of about €250. That average hides two groups moving in opposite directions:

  • about 3.5 million families gain, on average €600 a year;
  • nearly 3 million families lose, on average just over €200 a year. Most are families with pensioners who do not benefit from the income tax change.

Istat says the poorest fifth of families gets the largest benefit, but more than three quarters of the families affected are in the two richest fifths.

The UPB reached a similar conclusion on the income tax change. Its president, Lilia Cavallari, told the committees that it mainly helps higher earners: 89% of managers benefit, by €444 on average, against 12% of office workers and 1% of manual workers (LaPresse).

Why pensioners lose

Italian pensions rise each January to follow inflation, but higher pensions get only part of the increase. Under the current system, each slice of a pension is indexed at its own rate. The bill replaces this with bands: the whole pension gets one rate, set by the band it falls into. The thresholds are multiples of the minimum pension, €611.85 a month.

Pension, as a multiple of the minimumCurrent system (by slice)2027 bill (whole pension)
Up to 4 times100%100%
4 to 5 times90%85%
5 to 6 times75%53%
6 to 8 times75%47%
8 to 10 times75%37%
Above 10 times75%32%

Istat estimates that about 3.5 million pensioners would receive about €510 a year less, before tax, in 2027. Because a lower pension also means less income tax, the net loss falls to about €290. For pensioners who also benefit from the income tax change, the average net loss is about €150. The UPB puts the losses at between €144 and €1,357 a year, and says they are permanent, because each year's smaller increase carries into the next. The government's technical report on the bill estimates the gross saving at €14.2 billion over 2027 to 2036 (AGI).

The Court of Auditors said on 9 November that the banded system penalises medium and medium-high pensions. It noted that the Constitutional Court has upheld similar cuts in the past but asked for "less uncertain mechanisms" (QuiFinanza).

Fiscal drag: higher tax without a new law

Fiscal drag happens when tax brackets and allowances stay fixed while prices rise. A pay rise that only keeps up with inflation pushes part of a person's income into a higher bracket, so they pay more tax in real terms without any law changing.

Istat compared the two effects over 2021 to 2027:

  • tax reforms in that period gave each taxpayer a cumulative benefit of about €1,000 on average;
  • fiscal drag took about €1,100.

The balance differs by group. Employees come out about €50 a year ahead; pensioners lose more than €350 a year. Taxpayers earning under €20,000 gain overall. Above that, losses grow with income, up to €476 cumulative for those earning more than €60,000.

Istat estimates fiscal drag at about €6.5 billion in 2026, with inflation at 3.4%, €5.4 billion in 2027 (2.8%) and €3.5 billion in 2028 (1.7%).

What the government and its critics say

Economy Minister Giancarlo Giorgetti, of the League (Lega), told the committees on 12 November that the "load-bearing walls" of the bill will not be touched, while smaller parts can change if each change is paid for. On pensions he spoke of "an incredible disparity, which in my view is also unconstitutional" between people who started contributing before and after 1996, when Italy began moving to a system based on contributions paid, and said he was open to forms of flexibility that keep the system sustainable (LaPresse). Foreign Minister and Forza Italia leader Antonio Tajani has called the budget "serious and responsible" (AGI, 1 November).

The Court of Auditors also pointed out that the income tax cut lasts only one year: from 2028 the 43% rate returns for income between €50,000 and €55,000, which means up to €500 more tax at the same income.

On the opposition side, Francesco Boccia, who leads the Democratic Party (PD) senators, said the government "cuts schools and pensions" to pay for handouts. Angelo Bonelli of the Greens and Left Alliance (AVS) called the bill a "social robbery" (AGI). We did not find a position from the Five Star Movement (M5S) on the pension change. The CGIL, Italy's largest trade union, has called a general strike against the budget for 20 November. Federmanager, which represents managers, has asked for article 55 to be deleted.

What happens next

The committees will vote on amendments, then the bill goes to the floor of the Chamber and then the Senate. Istat's figures describe the bill as presented: any change to the pension bands or the tax brackets would change who wins and who loses.

Sources

Istat, hearing on the 2027 budget bill (C. 3174-bis), 11 November 2026; L'Espresso, 11 November 2026; Fanpage, 11 November 2026; LaPresse, 13 November 2026; QuiFinanza, 9 November 2026 (Court of Auditors); AGI, 1 November 2026.

More in Economy & Money · Politics · Society

See the post on Instagram

Found this useful? The Italy Desk is free to read. A small tip helps us keep it that way.

Support us on Ko-fi

Keep reading.

This Week in Italy, in your inbox.

Every Friday we send the week's Italian news in one short read. It's free.

We send it through Substack, which opens in a new tab. You can unsubscribe with one click.